Buying from Misfits Market and Traditional Grocery Store Comparison

In my last post I talked about using Misfits Market, an online grocery source. I have run some numbers to show you a comparison between Misfits and my local grocery store prices.

Please keep in mind what Misfits offers is organic produce. What I compared at my local grocery store was NOT organic. If the items compared were both organic the price comparison would have been very different. The local grocery stores cannot compete with Misfits on organic produce prices. Hands down Misfits wins.

But let’s see which shopping experience is cheaper in general if cost is purely the attraction.

MisfitsGrocery Store
Green Beans$3.99/lb$2.49/lb
Grape Tomatoes$3.19 pt$3.49 pt
Romaine Hearts 3ct$3.99$4.49
White Mushrooms$2.29 8oz$2.99 8oz
Brussels Sprouts$3.99/lb$2.99/lb
Baby Bella Mushrooms$2.49 8oz$3.49 8oz
Total cost if purchased all$27.92$26.42

After the price comparison as you can see the traditional store is technically cheaper by about $1.50 but is that incentive enough to not shop online? I guess you would have to weigh the pros and cons. There are traditional stores that might be cheaper like an Aldi or Save-A-Lot. A larger traditional store like a Wegmans or Tops would definitely be higher priced but then there is Walmart which usually is even cheaper.

I guess it all comes down to what works for you. Remember there is a delivery fee with Misfits that is not factored into this cost comparison which was $5.50 for me last week. AND don’t forget Misfits wants you to order a minimum of $30 per delivery. (plus delivery charge).

I am not ordering from Misfits this week. The beans and Brussels sprouts look better at my local store and I want to support my son and family and friends that work there. That means more to me than having the convenience of having a box dropped at my door.

My goal in the spring, summer and fall is to grow all of my own produce and eat with the seasons. Except for maybe corn. Corn takes up a lot of space, which I don’t have.

What do you think of buying groceries online?

Next update – the grocery shopping habits of my friend Rebecca! – MM

Published by marymargaretripley

I am a professional Bakery Manager at a privately owned grocery store. I also owned my own bakery for over four years. I have been baking for 15+ years professionally. I also teach canning and preserving classes and have been gardening since I was 5 years old. I live in Western, NY with my husband, teenage son, Bernie the Cat and Muffins the Hamster.

3 thoughts on “Buying from Misfits Market and Traditional Grocery Store Comparison

  1. I use misfits at this time of year when my local produce is pretty much root vegetables and greens, which I purchase with great appreciation. The Misfits prices versus organic produce at the local grocery store and co-ops isna bit cheaper and in this time of Covid if I can avoid a trip to the supermarket for a $5 delivery fee, I’m there!


  2. I buy from a store. However, during lockdown I bought my green groceries from an online store, the one I usually visited. The online problem I found was that I had no control over the quality. In person I can choose the best looking celery or smell the tomatoes. So there was more waste buying online.


  3. I have never bought online, but them my life is much less complicated than most people’s! I travel 25 feet to my office, and have three mornings free for grocery acquisition, plus DH does lots of food shopping, and we eat from the pantry, so the grocery list is very small. 😁


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

One Hundred Dollars a Month

How I feed my family with $100 a month - gardening, frugal living, recipes - with fun along the way!

Gardening Nirvana

Sharing my journey in and out of the garden

The Snail of Happiness

small steps to a kinder world

Cocktails In The Library

Talking about great books while enjoying tasty libations!

Autumn Leaves & A Spring Breeze

Leading a happy and sustainable lifestyle

Midwest mattie

just living my best life in the midwest.

Sewing Beside the Sea

All things made with my needle and thread


Making and creating

Sewing Etc.

Sharing my adventures in sewing and needlearts

Debt Free Hopeful

“Love recognizes no barriers. It jumps hurdles, leaps fences, penetrates walls to arrive at its destination full of hope.” — Maya Angelou


Outrageous mama saying Fuck It

The Journey to a Debt-Free Life

Reshaping your Financial Future

Cottage Garden Trio

The daily life and times of a thirty something couple and their toddler

McMuffins Gaming

From the Mind of a Gamer

Claire93's Blog

my little corner in blogland

Ever The Crafter

She, ever the crafter, kept on crafting

Emma's Craft Projects

Everyday craft inspirations

Bake. Make. Take (a trip!)

Celebrating the "funner" things in life...

Peas Romaine Calm

A simple, easy & cost effective approach to cooking!

%d bloggers like this: